San Rafael Heritage
  • Home
    • Board of Directors
    • Heritage Herald Newsletter >
      • Archived Newsletters
  • This Place Matters
    • In the News
    • Save The Depot >
      • Depot Historic Timeline
      • How You Can Help!
    • Boyd Gatehouse
    • TPM Archives >
      • Fire Station 51
  • Membership
  • Resources
  • Contact Us
  • Historic Preservation Events
  • Links to Preservation Organizations
  • Home
    • Board of Directors
    • Heritage Herald Newsletter >
      • Archived Newsletters
  • This Place Matters
    • In the News
    • Save The Depot >
      • Depot Historic Timeline
      • How You Can Help!
    • Boyd Gatehouse
    • TPM Archives >
      • Fire Station 51
  • Membership
  • Resources
  • Contact Us
  • Historic Preservation Events
  • Links to Preservation Organizations

CONNECT WITH 
​SAN RAFAEL HERITAGE!

Picture
Picture
Picture

Picture

San Rafael high-rise housing plan gets 16 floors lopped off.
 Includes comments from 
SRH Board members

Picture
The developer behind a proposal for a 24-story apartment complex in downtown San Rafael has reduced the plan to eight stories.

In addition to shedding 16 stories, the latest iteration of the “4th Street Market Hall and Residences” plan also reduces the number of apartments from 345 to 197. The project would have nine designated affordable dwellings, down from 52 in the larger plan.

The applicant also plans to pay an in-lieu fee of about $3.5 million to the city’s affordable housing trust fund to fulfill its affordable housing obligation.

The new application, unlike the previous one, is for independent living apartments restricted to residents 55 and older. The project still includes about 25,000 square feet of ground-floor commercial space on Fourth Street.

The application materials offer no explanation of what motivated the changes. The project developer, Paul Goldstone of Goldstone Management Inc. in Berkeley, did not respond to a request for comment.

Goldstone had floated the idea of a similar but smaller project in 2018.

“The type of housing a developer proposes is the applicant’s choice,” said Angela Robinson-Piñon, assistant city manager. “The city reviews every application against the same adopted standards. San Rafael needs more housing of all types. The applicant has identified their target market as active seniors. Older adults are a growing share of the community, and Marin County has one of the oldest populations in California.”

The project site is 1.4 acres across from the Bank of America Building at the City Plaza. The plan is for an L-shaped building that would combine six parcels at 1099, 1017, 1009 and 1001 Fourth St. and a lot on Third Street.                
The existing structures would be demolished. The project would wrap around the recently approved eight-story building at 900 A St. on two sides.

The formal project application, submitted on Oct. 5, follows a preliminary application that was filed in April under Senate Bill 330. That ensured that any formal application submitted within a 180-day period would be subject only to regulations in place at the time he filed the preliminary application.

Under SB 330, the city may hold no more than five public hearings on the project, including appeals. The city must only apply adopted objective standards when deciding whether to approve, condition or deny the development application.
The preliminary application also invoked a categorical exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act under Assembly Bill 130.  
         
The application states that because more than 35 apartments for seniors are provided, the plan qualifies for a 20% density bonus under state law, enabling up to 212 residences.
Through the state density bonus law, the applicant seeks waivers from city requirements for floor-area ratio, building height, stepbacks and bicycle parking.

The floor-area ratio waiver would enable the developer to construct 58 apartments more than the zoning allows for the lot size. The project would be just short of 85 feet high, about 25 feet higher than the city’s height limit. The zoning district requires 10-foot stepbacks. The project proposes none.

The project proposes 173 bicycle parking spaces, down from the 286 required by the city. The project would provide 261 car parking spaces in a garage accessed from Third Street.
The commercial area would include an arcade that “creates a public open space/civic space and a widened sidewalk on 4th Street, providing an inviting relationship between the Market Hall interior and public exterior, and satisfying the civic open space requirement,” the application says.

Members of San Rafael Heritage applauded the changes. In a letter to the developer, Sue Burrell, vice president of the preservation group, said the new plan “will be immensely better in bringing more housing to downtown San Rafael in a way that fits the surrounding neighborhood.” Burrell encouraged the developer to “include design elements that give a nod to our historic downtown. New developments can enhance the character of longstanding neighborhoods in a beautiful way,” she said.

Jeff Rhoads, an architect who is a member of the group, said being across the street from the City Plaza makes this an important project. “This could be a really catalytic project for our city if it’s done well … particularly if it’s designed sensitively to be a good fit into our downtown, and ultimately supports the retail activity and liveliness of Fourth Street,” he said. Rhoads said he is concerned about the age-restricted residences. He understands there is a need for older adults to move to smaller residences and free up houses. 
“But we really want a diverse community downtown both demographically and age,” he said. “We really need young people downtown to help enliven our downtown.”

Jenny Silva, executive director of the nonprofit organization Call Marin Home, said it is “in favor of whatever enables this project to move forward.”

“San Rafael needs homes, and many approved projects have not yet broken ground,” Silva said. “We don’t know why the project was restructured, and we don’t want to assume. It could have been driven by financing and construction costs, and a smaller project may be easier to finance and build. If so, that’s good news. A project that gets built beats a bigger one that doesn’t.”
Silva said she is concerned about the reduction in affordable housing, saying a $3.5 million in-lieu contribution “won’t replace the homes lost in this proposal.”

Silva said that ideally the project would involve workforce and low-income housing, but she understands that housing is hard to finance right now.

“Senior housing meets a real need, and Marin’s older residents are a growing share of our population,” Silva said. “But the greatest need is affordable senior housing.”
​
Robinson-Piñon said the application is under review.


New San Rafael walking tour
​brings history to life


Read Vice President Sue Burrell's Commentary in the Marin IJ:
San Rafael needs to take next step for historic preservation  


CLICK HERE TO READ
THE HERITAGE HERALD NEWSLETTER!


2026 Preservation Award at City Hall

San Rafael Heritage Vice-President Sue Burrell presented our 2026 Preservation Award, May 4th at City Hall, to the Carnegie Library for their recent renovation.  Catherine Quffa, Library & Recreation Director accepted the award. The certificate read:
In recognition of the excellent 2025 restoration and enhancement of this 1909 historic building and important cultural resource honoring its history, architecture and character, and its ongoing cultural significance to our community. 
Picture
SRH member Emese Wood, VP Sue Burrell, Catherine Quffa, SRH board member Laura Ackley

Watch video from our Saturday, April 18th meeting At Historic Studio Fourth Street
With Heather McPhail Sridharan, Marin History Museum President
​

Preservation Award to the Carnegie Library
Cityscape Award to Aegis Living


Followed by a panel on:

The Intersection of Downtown Development & Historic Preservation
Shall we get in on the ground floor of a 24-story development?

Mission Statement

To promote the preservation of San Rafael’s historic resources and architecturally significant 
buildings and to support other historical and preservationist organizations in Marin County.

Goals

  1. Focus on the growth of the organization
  2. Work with the City for implementation of the Downtown Precise Plan and placemaking as it relates to historic preservation
  3. Establish working relationships with the City’s Departments of Community Development, Library and Recreation, and the City Manager’s office
  4. Pursue our partnership with the Marin History Museum
  5. Create space on our website to provide information about historic preservation and relevant regulations, laws, and resources

Memberships are now Tax - Deductible!
Join or RENEW now and your membership will run through 2026!
​      ​See our Membership Page